Battle between Faith and Skepticism
DR.PASHA | December 22, 2011 | Section: Articles | 770 reads
Read offline:
Battle between Faith and Skepticism
Dr. Pasha
The battle of wits between the advocates of Faith and Skepticism never advanced much beyond the argument that Hazrat Ali, Radiyallahu Anhu, put forward 1400 years ago.
Hazrat Ali wrote a little couplet in which he said this – he was a great poet and literary figure by the way, among so many other things:
“The physicist and the physician both claimed,
There was no resurrection and no day of judgment.
To this I said: Fine, have it your way!
If, I then pointed out,
Things after death turn out the way you say,
I will not be in any trouble at all;
But if, on the other hand,
Should things turn out the way I say,
Imagine what your fate will be.”
This debate between Belief and Disbelief is a matter of considerable personal interest to me and I have followed it keenly over several decades in person and over centuries in books.
And let me say two things:
a) First of all, Hazrat Ali’s argument is as calm, cool and rational as it can be.
b) Second, I have not seen either the physicist or the physician, as Hazrat Ali, Radiyallahu Anhu, calls them, or anyone else, come up with a satisfactory counter to this most eloquent argument by Hazrat Ali.
So far as I can judge, the ball is still in the court of the Skeptics.
As for that Haiku-type little poem by Hazrat Ali, Radiyallahu Anhu, here it is in original Arabic:
Za’amal munajjimu wat-tabeebu kilaahumaa;
Allaa ma’aada, fa-qultu dhaaka ilaikumaa.
In sahha qawulukumaa, fa-lastu bi-khwaasirin;
Awu sahha qawulee, fal-wabaalu alaikumaa!
END
© 2011 Syed Husain Pasha
Dr. Pasha is an educator and scholar of exceptional
talent, training and experience. He can be reached at DrSyedPasha [at]
AOL [dot] com or www.IslamicSolutions.com.
Shortlink:
Jump to Article:
Related content
I am saying miraculous because I have no other word in the English language to describe it. It is so amazing, what I am about to talk about, and stupendous and so absolutely unbelievable that I don’t know what else ...
READ MOREWith regard to anything, just because you don't see it does not mean it is not there.
For, as all educated people know -- or they should know -- that with regard to anything: "Absence of Evidence" is by no means ...
READ MOREFaith is a risk either way. Whether you believe in God or you don’t believe in him, the final outcome is always uncertain.
That is so, no matter how much True Believers deny it is so. [...]
READ MOREHumans have a predictable trajectory in life. Some a bit different than some others in some minor details no doubt. But the basic process -- and the basic beginning and end -- is all the same.
We are all born weak ...
READ MOREThink about Him, Not about You. Don’t think about who you are: Hindu, Jew, Christian or Muslim. Rich, poor, black, white, man, woman. Instead focus and concentrate on who HE is: God of All. God of love. God of mercy ...
READ MOREWhat seems to matter most to some of our super-pious Muslims is not what life is like in this world – the way it is for us and for all other creation of God, right here and now – but what ...
READ MOREWhen we do or say something, others watch. And they listen.
And, when we think, no one is watching or listening, Allah is.
That is the difference between faith and lack of faith -- between being a Muslim and not being a ...
READ MOREThink about Him, Not about You. Don’t think about who you are: Hindu, Jew, Christian or Muslim. Rich, poor, black, white, man, woman. Instead focus and concentrate on who HE is: God of All. God of love. God of mercy ...
READ MOREThere is not a doubt that we are all on our return journey to God – each and every one of us.
The Qur’an makes that categorically clear.
Wa Inaa Ilaihi Raaji’oon!
Paraphrase:
“We are all marching back to God!”
The first step in this ...
READ MOREThis other news, the one about the Narrow Cylindrical Dark Hole, 10 feet deep, and the 10 feet of dirt on top, can be Good or Bad, depending on who you were...
READ MOREI don't get it. I just don't.
I don't get the fact that Muslims don't seem to get it.
And I don't get the fact that the Non-Muslims and the world don't seem to get it.
They all seem to have some vague ...
READ MOREEvery man's -- and I suppose every woman's -- "permanent" address, as they call it, in this most obviously and stubbornly impermanent world, is as follows:
Name: whatever that is
Door Number: whatever that is
Street: whatever that is
Town, city or village: whatever ...
READ MOREMany Instances of Oppression, Suffering and Pain,
But Every Time the Same Guilty, Culpable Silence!
(With apologies to Martin Niemoller, a Protestant pastor in Nazi Germany.)
(The stanza on Muslims is added. But it is breathtakingly apt.)
First they came for the Communists,
And I ...
READ MOREI feel I am trivializing it by putting it this way, but that is the image that comes to mind. And it is not even apt or appropriate, really.
But when I see people falling over themselves, and not even minding ...
READ MORE“Pleasure for many people is the path they pursue through life. Pain is often the price they pay for many of the pleasures they seek in this world. Islam modulates pleasure, and optimizes it, while minimizing pain and distancing it. ...
READ MORE"When our body is sick, it is only our life in this world that may be at risk. For, death will surely put an end to all bodily pain and suffering.
And then there is the hope of eternal bliss for ...
READ MORE"Islam places in the hands of all of us a most personal and intimate miracle: How to defy death every time it strikes.
Here is how.
“Everything shall perish,” the Qur’an declares, “except him!”
Reference is to God.
Islam defines human mortality in a ...
READ MOREGeorge Bush (Jr.), former president of the United States, once said he was the decider. Well, I have news for him.
In the real world, the world in which all decisions are made and count, the only decider is Allah – ...
READ MOREHumanity was sick, Islam came to heal it.
Humanity is back to being sick again. It needs Islam, once again, to make it well and whole.
It needs the Qur’an.
Allahu Akbar, should that alone not wake up human beings today to the ...
READ MORE"When things go wrong – and they often do – people look for someone to blame. Often, they find it easier to blame others than to hold themselves accountable.
“Scapegoating” is an old idea. It is in the Bible – the Old ...
READ MORE"Human beings are like little children on a playground. They are too busy with their toys and too excited about playing.
It does not occur to them that at any moment their mother will call them and they will have to ...
READ MOREAccountability is a most important aspect of a Muslim’s life. And this accountability is not just before God Almighty, the Creator. It is also before each and every one of his creation.
Because God’s creation has a stake in what goes ...
READ MOREBut what most people seem to be clueless about is a simple fact of empirical, verifiable data...
READ MOREThe Most Miraculous Human Face
Introducing God into the Equation: Who Wrote Our DNA Code Do You Think?
Give God a Break! [Quote 508]
What Other Options Do Humans Have?
Why Do We Worry So Much about Typos – And other Errors in Our Writings?
Saga of Human Life: From God and To God! [Quote – 701]
World Day of God – 2016/1437
Thinking about Allah and Us
Some Muslims Forget that This World Is Gateway to the Next World [Quote – 184]
How Different People Seem to Live Their Lives
Saying and Doing the Right Thing [Quote – 716]
World Day of God
Two Approaches to Life – Or Is It Death? [Quote – 733]
From Two Feet of Snow to 10 Feet of Dirt
Clueless Muslims, Clueless World! [Quote – 765]
Seeking Permanence Where There Is None [Quote 621]
Many Instances of Oppression, Suffering and Pain, But Every Time the Same Guilty, Culpable Silence! [Quote 616]
[My Log – 5] Whale of a Sale
Pleasure-Pain Principle [Quote – 263]
A Sick Body vs. a Sick Soul [Quote – 294]
The Islamic Miracle of Defying Death [Quote – 299]
Who Is the Decider?
Islam Is All about Health and Wellbeing
Who Is To Blame [Quote – 342]
Children on the Playground [363]
We Are Accountable – before God and His Creation [Quote 435]
Two Realities: Visible and Invisible
A Concept Called Accountability
Clueless Muslims, Clueless World!
Home | Writings | Audio | Quote-Unquote
