In the name of God, the most Merciful, the most Merciful!

IslamicSolutions.Com

New Literature for a New Era

Education at its best -- for both Muslims and non-Muslims.

Authentic. Unique. Powerful. Readable. Absorbing.
Accessible. Electrifying. Groundbreaking.

Driving Islam Home to the World -- One Concept at a Time!

See Islam for all that Islam really is:

Peaceable! Positive! Simple! Sensible! Elegant! Civilized! Constructive! Hopeful! Contemporary! Pragmatic! Problem-Solving! Moderate! Modern! Balanced! Just! Fair! Compassionate! Truthful! Nice! Easy! Fun! Global! Divine! Authentic! Original! Free! (Dr. Pasha)

EXPAND

Are Transliterations of the Qur’an Haram?

DR.PASHA | January 30, 2014 | Section: Articles | 2854 reads


Read offline:


Are Transliterations of the Qur’an Haram?

Dr. Pasha

Are Transliterations of the Qur’an Haram? Both doing them and reading them?

It is time Muslims addressed this issue squarely and urgently. And here is my reasoning why I consider this issue to be important.

God sent the Qur’an to all of humanity to read – both Muslims and non-Muslims alike.

That means the Qur’an is a book that God sent to the whole world and not just to this or that group of people in any particular time.

Or place.

The word “Qur’an” means “To Read.”

Or “To Recite,” as some people would say.

Or “Reading.”

Or “Recitation.”

That means everyone everywhere must read the Qur’an: in whatever language they can and however much of it they can.

In whatever place or time they can.

The Qur’an of course is in Arabic. That is the language in which God sent it into this world. And that is the language in which the Qur’an has stayed all these 1400-plus years.

So, the right and proper way to read the Qur’an is in its original Arabic text.

But for those of us who cannot read the Qur’an in Arabic, we must read a translation of the Qur’an in whatever language we can. Even as we strive to learn to read it in the original Arabic language in which God Almighty chose to send it down to earth.

But translation is not Transliteration. The difference is critical.

Translation means rendering the meaning or sense of a text – words – of some kind from one language in a different language. Such as, for example, translating an Arabic, Persian, German or French text of some kind – let us say a poem or a letter written by a political leader to someone – into another language, such as English or Swahili.

That is translation.

Transliteration, on the other hand, is the attempt to render the very words of one language (let us say Arabic or German for example) into another language (let us say Tamil or English), using the script and alphabets of the second language – the host language if you will.

Thus, Transliteration of the Qur’an would mean the attempt to write the words of the Qur’an using script from another language such as English or modern post-1920 Turkish or Tamil.

Such an undertaking, where Qur’an is concerned, is an impossibility to accomplish successfully. That means the words of the Qur’an cannot successfully and accurately be rendered into another language using the host script, such as Roman or Tamil or Cyrillic alphabet.

This in turn means that the new text of the Qur’an, created in a different language such as English or Tamil or Cyrillic, cannot possibly be considered Qur’an by any stretch of the imagination.

As a result, those who read the Qur’an in Transliteration are not reading the Qur’an, period. They are reading something else – something other than the Qur’an – no matter how well or faithfully the Transliteration job might have been accomplished.

Nor do intentions matter in this context. It does not really matter how pure or perfect or noble or innocent the intentions of those doing the Transliteration may have been.

For, in spite of their best intentions, there is no earthly way for them to render the heavenly text and language of the Qur’an accurately into earthly scripts from other languages such as Tamil, English or Cyrillic.

Their products will always be wrong, defective and erroneous, no matter what their credentials and qualifications, and no matter how pure and lofty their goals and intentions.

And the Noble Qur’an by its very nature is free from all defect, doubt and error: Laa Rayiba Feehi!

That is why Muslims must seriously consider the question if it should be Haram for Muslims to do a Transliteration of the Qur’an, for any purpose other than perhaps the most narrow and specific scholarly ones.

In the same way, should it also be Haram for Muslims to read a Transliteration of the Qur’an in any language other than Arabic.

For, both these activities – doing Transliteration as well as reading it – would fall under the broad definition of doing Tahreef or adulteration of the pure and perfect text of the Qur’an.

That is why Muslims have no choice but to learn to read the Qur’an in its original Arabic language, regardless of whether they are new coverts to Islam or old heritage-type born in Muslim homes.

Even though this may appear at first blush a daunting task, learning to read the Qur’an in its original Arabic text, God Almighty has made a most emphatic promise to them in the Qur’an – and repeated it four times in one Surah or chapter of the Qur’an, chapter 54, called Al-Qamar – that he will make their job easy for them.

END

 

Shortlink:
Next:

Previous:

Jump to Article:

Related content
Pray tell me, Muslims! Just how did we Muslims manage to accomplish this feat? Just how did we manage to abandon the Qur'an? We, whom Allah blessed to be the bearers, keepers, servants and custodians of the Qur'an in this world. We, ...
READ MORE
It is not happening as yet, but one day Insha Allah, soon, very soon, there will be a continuum of reading of Allah's book, the Qur'an, across the world, a la Tawaaf around the Ka'abah, which only stops five times a day ...
READ MORE
Call to All to Read the Qur’an Dr. Firdaus today issued a call to Muslims around the world to organize Weekly Khatm Sharif of the Qur’an between now and the next Ramadan, 1434/2013. Dr. Fridaus says the word Qur’an means “To Read” ...
READ MORE
Dr. Pasha has issued a call to Muslims around the world – in every single Mohalla and every single Community, in every part of the world – to get organized from now on to be able to do a Grand ...
READ MORE
It was 1971, in Trinidad & Tobago, West Indies, the Caribbean – and of course everywhere else. Some of us started then to teach some of the others among us how to read the Qur'an. This 1400-year-old book on this earth from ...
READ MORE
The Qur’an, every single word of it, is the most glorious word of Almighty Allah – direct; unadulterated; pure; authentic; original; and clear. It was revealed by Allah to Prophet Muhammad, Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam, to be a complete guide for humanity ...
READ MORE
It was several decades ago when the late Maherul Qadri wrote his beautiful and evocative poem he called Qur’an ki Faryaad. Paraphrase: “Complaint of the Qur’an.” The basic theme of the poem was something like this: They love me and they kiss me; They ...
READ MORE
Humanity was sick, Islam came to heal it. Humanity is back to being sick again. It needs Islam, once again, to make it well and whole. It needs the Qur’an. Allahu Akbar, should that alone not wake up human beings today to the ...
READ MORE
Many of us confuse reality with religion. That is why it is important for me to explain how Islam is not “religion” but reality. Islam is Al-Haqq. Translation: Reality. Islam is divine, from beginning to end. Religion is man-made. Religion is presided over ...
READ MORE
Here are two things that are absolutely, positively required of all Muslims, so far as the Qur'an is concerned: 1. First of all, all Muslims -- men as well as women -- must learn to read the Qur'an, properly and correctly, ...
READ MORE
It was a trip I was supposed to be too ill to make. It was an unlikely trip. But the trip was made anyway. Allah made it happen -- as Allah makes everything happen. And on that trip I met a man -- ...
READ MORE
Allah's path is clear -- and straight. And that path is the path of the Qur'an. It is the Qur'an. Allah did not put any crookedness in it. [...]
READ MORE
Generally speaking, Shaitan -- the Devil -- seems to be a happy-go-lucky kind of a guy. But there seems to be one thing that bothers him more than all the other things in this world. And that is the Qur'an. Often, Shaitan's ...
READ MORE
World Muslims and non-Muslims must celebrate 12th Rabi’ul Awwal, 1433 – 5th February, 2012 – as World Day of Qur’an for Universal Male-Female Literacy. And they must do the same thing consistently every year thereafter – on every 12th Rabiul Awwal. And ...
READ MORE
Rasulullah, Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam, tells us that Du’a that is made after reading the Qur’an is accepted.
READ MORE
If you are interested in organizing a Qur'an program in your area, please contact me, and I will tell you what you need to do to get a programme going in your area. I strongly urge you to give this idea ...
READ MORE
And once the Qur’an begins to “talk,” all one can do is just to sit there, open oneself to the cascading light and Rahmah of the Qur’an and keep chanting Alhamdulillah, Subhanallah, Allahu Akbar and La Ilaha Illallah, as the ...
READ MORE
Every day, every Muslim must ask himself or herself: When did I last see the Qur'an? When did I last touch the Qur'an? When did I last hold the Qur'an in my hand? When did I last open the Qur'an? When did I last turn ...
READ MORE
The Qur'an says think logically. And think incrementally. Approach this problem like you would approach most problems in life. First of all, decide if the universe had a creator what would he be like? He would be most powerful and most ...
READ MORE
“If you are a Muslim, it is your duty to take the Qur’an to every home and heart that needs it — and which one does not. But if you are not a Muslim, shouldn’t you try to find out what ...
READ MORE
The topics below have been covered in the past Qur'an program or they will be covered in the future program, In-sha'Allah. Topics will be repeated as needed.
READ MORE
Many of the miracles of the Qur'an we can see with our own eyes. Having seen them, we need to ask where we stand in relation to them. Do we accept them and embrace the Qur'an as the word of ...
READ MORE
In the name of Allah, The most merciful, The most merciful. [...]
READ MORE
The Qur'an program has been offered by Dr. Pasha on either side of the Atlantic. And by the grace and mercy of Almighty Allah it has been most successful everywhere. In this program, Dr. Pasha uses the language of the Qur'an ...
READ MORE
“Qur’an!” Is The Answer!
Reading Qur’an around the World
Dr. Firdaus Tells World Muslims: “Do Weekly Khatm between Now and Next Ramadan!”
Dr. Pasha Calls for Grand Global Khatm-a-Day for Ramadan 1434
1971-2012: What a Timeline!
QUR’AN READING MADE EASY
Muslims Abusing the Qur’an
Islam Is All about Health and Wellbeing
Islam and Its Method: Or Just Say Al-Kitab wal Hikmah Part I
A Call to All! This Blessed Month of Ramadan, Try the Qur’an!
Qur’an: Two Things Muslims Must do [Quote 540]
Qur’an to The Rescue
A Trip and a Man and a Book [Quote – 720]
Help Save the World: A Call to Action by Dr. Pasha!
Allah’s path is clear — straight
Shaitan and the Qur’an [Quote 612]
This Ramadan, Let Us Revisit the Qur’an Scale!
For Qur’an, Always Save Your Best
Urgent! Things Muslims Must Do – Over and Above All Things They Must
Dr. Pasha Calls for World Day of Qur’an for Universal Male-Female Literacy!
A Du’a for One of Our Khatm Al-Qur’an
Get Involved, Start the Qur’an Program in Your Area – Here is How!
Let Us Reconnect with the Qur’an!
Dr. Pasha’s Qur’an Scale
Discover the Qur’an – A Reality Check
Statement of Purpose: Dr. Pasha’s International Qur’an Program
Some Topics Related to the Qur’an
How to Read a Translation of the Qur’an
An English Translation of Surah Al-Faatihah
Feedback on Dr. Pasha’s International Qur’an Program

Home | Writings | Audio | Quote-Unquote